PC Magazine picks Cingular 8525 as editors’ choice with very good rating of 4 out of 5 and comments that Cingular 8525 will keep you connected to the Internet at the highest speed possible wherever you go (given the limitations of Cingular’s network), and you won’t miss a single call while you’re online. Good for HSDPA and Wi-Fi for high-speed Internet, zippy Samsung processor and stereo Bluetooth, but it comes with not the greatest keyboard, earpiece could be louder and some hiss on calls.
CNet reviews Cingular 8525 and concludes with excellent rating of 8 out of 10 that the Cingular 8525 is the first UMTS/HSDPA smart phone to be offered in the United States. It has integrated Bluetooth 2.0, Wi-Fi, and supports Cingular’s new location-based services. The Windows Mobile device also has push e-mail capabilities, a 2-megapixel camera, a spacious QWERTY keyboard, and good call quality. However, the Cingular 8525 is on the heavier side and the navigation array is a bit cramped. The smart phone is also pricey. For the ultimate road warrior, the 3G-enabled Cingular 8525 provides the speed, the power, and the productivity tools to get your work done on the go.
infoSync World gives very good score of 84% to 8525 and concludes that “simply glancing over the robust specifications of this HSDPA-enabled smartphone was enough to make us drool, and for the most part, the 8525 lived up to our expectations. The phone is fast in every way: over the 3G network, Wi-Fi, and even the Bluetooth 2.0 connection. The Cingular 8525 comes with ample messaging capabilities, including push e-mail, and its sharp dual-orientation display makes the phone’s calendar and today screens a joy to use. Unfortunately, the buggy, if comfortable, keypad gave us headaches (we can only hope our pre-production test unit is to blame), and the typical foibles of Windows Mobile 5.0 made browsing Office documents something of a pain. That said, the 8525 ranks as one of the most impressive Windows Mobile smartphones we’ve tested.”
MobileTechReview reviews HTC TyTN (nearly identical with Cingular 8525, both of code name HTC Hermes variants) and concludes that it’s an excellent device for power users who need to do email, view and edit Word and Excel documents, view PowerPoint presentations and PDFs on the go and surf the web. Not just a business device, the Cingular 8525 and TyTN are great multimedia playmates with good support for music and video playback. Compared to their MS Smartphone counterparts they’re more easily customizable and there’s a great selection of 3rd party software to extend both business and pleasure use. As the first 3G PDA phone and smartphone announced in the US, the 8525 has special appeal to those who use the web and email heavily, assuming you’re in a 3G coverage area. The faster processor, HSDPA 3G radio, better camera and Bluetooth 2.0 make it a worthy successor to the Cingular 8125 and company, though only you can decide if the price difference is worth it. If you’re a heavy PDA user, the 8525 wins. If you prefer a one-handed phone centric device, the Palm Treo 750v 3G Windows Mobile Pocket PC phone may be worth the wait.
Laptop Magazine (dead link) gives 4 out of 5 rating to Cingular 8525 PDA and concludes that at $399, the 8525 is considerably more expensive than other Cingular smart phones, such as the Nokia E62 ($149 with rebate) and the Treo 600 or 8125 (both $249). Still, the faster HSDPA connection—when you’re within coverage—large keyboard and display, flexible Bluetooth profiles, and more robust software make the 8525 a top-flight PDA phone.