Gizmodo did a full review on Zune and concluded that “this seems pretty promising. I can’t find any mis-steps or anything where I have to ask “wait, this is dumb, why did you do this?” in both the player and the software. The Zune itself is very sexy, and feels nice to the touch—not too heavy. We can’t wait to do another hands on as the launch date approaches. Oh, and I still can’t decide which color is my favorite.”
coolfer (link dead) was given a presentation on Zune and had a chance to hand on the pre-final Zune, and after reviewing, concluded that “though I didn’t have hands-on experience with the Zune software and store (information about those came from a Flash presentation given by the senior director of product management), I did get a good working knowledge of the Zune system, and I did get my hands on one of the devices for a few minutes. I’ll save thoughts on market viability for later. Right now I’ll say that what I saw of the Zune impressed me. The device is attractive and feels good in the hand. Its interface is clean and user-friendly. The flag feature and the friend-to-friend (wireless) capabilities show it’s a forward-thinking device. Microsoft isn’t attempting to re-create the established digital experience. The Zune hints at the future of digital entertainment.” Stereogum (link dead) sneaked peek at Zune pre-production model few months ago and concludes that Microsoft has introduced features to which Apple must, and will, respond. Wirelessly transferring tracks – be it device to device, device to computer, or device to music store – is a logical evolutionary step. Making personal pictures into wallpaper? Sure, why not, that too. But realistically, Zune has a few-months window within which to advance the possibilities their new technology offers; with aggressive marketing and smart management, there is hope for Zune to grow into the profitable, user-friendly community Microsoft envisions. But, as it stands, Apple has the image, the loyalty, and the market share. 2old2play (link dead) reviews Zune portable media player and concludes that “all in all, any reservations I had about the device melted away after I had a few moments with the Zune. Yes, it is a first-generation product but I really like the direction Microsoft is taking with the Zune. Regardless of either the Zune or the iPod, the consumer will be the winner of this new front in the battle for our entertainment lifestyle. Though I really enjoy the few moments today with the Zune, I secretly look forward to Apples response. Hopefully it will be better than dealing massive damage to the giant enemy crab’s weak point.”
Junk Drawer reviews Zune after product demo few months back that for as cool as the Zune looks and runs on cursory inspection I don’t think it’ll inspire anyone to dump their Macs and run pell mell to the Windows platform vis-a-vis the iPod’s power inspiring the reverse. But guess what? Microsoft couldn’t care less about Mac users. They’re banking on selling Zune to the millions who don’t have an iPod yet, and those who only have one MP3 device in their life. Shudder to think! As for all the Mac purists out there, hopefully Zune will force Apple to step it up and push the iPod to new heights instead of resting on its laurels and throwing out more storage or new colors occasionally.
Engadget has a hands on Zune and concludes with lots of photos gallery that the software seemed very responsive, especially search. As for the hardware, again, there isn’t much we can say at this point about the crippled functionality of the wireless, but if you haven’t already come to terms with what features the Zune is and isn’t launching with, then you might want to try and look at it for its merits as a player (while ignoring the wireless) — or simply keep looking for another device.
In its full review of Zune, Engadget concludes that “the Zune is a player riddled with a lot of small issues, death by a thousand cuts. Do we think any particular one is a deal breaker? Well, even given our nightmarish software issues, not really. Do we think they should have worked out the kinks and sat out this holiday season? Probably, yeah. Do we think there’s potential for betterment of the platform and especially the player through software updates? Given enough time, absolutely. Would we recommend the product for purchase, like, right now? Not a chance. People wonder whether Microsoft’s underdog will overtake Cupertino’s reigning juggernaut this holiday season. To be honest, we wish it could, since we too are getting kind of sick of seeing the iPod on top. A one man show is only entertaining for so long. But this buying season if the question is iPod, we’re afraid the answer sure isn’t Zune.”
CNet reviews Zune and concludes in its editors’ take that the Zune is a well-designed portable media device with good playback performance, a snappy processor, and an excellent interface. Wi-Fi sharing worked well, but prospective owners should know that its format support, especially for videos, is limited. The Zune looks like a good fit for MP3 player novices.
ComputerWorld (link dead) concludes that Zune Marketplace isn’t nearly as advanced as iTunes or, for that matter, some of the other subscription services. Besides not offering videos, podcasts are unavailable, and, with just over 2 million tracks, it offers far less music than iPod’s 3.5 million. Zune has some strong, even compelling features but also many areas that are underwhelming. It is the beginning of a work in progress that will be attractive to some users now. But many users will find that it is not quite ready for prime time. Popular Mechanics (link dead) summarizes that “until we can try out the Wi-Fi functions and the Zune Marketplace, it’s not completely fair to deliver a verdict, but we will anyway. This isn’t a great music player, but it’s a very decent video player. Unless the Wi-Fi features are phenomenal, the Zune is the husky, ugly cousin of the iPod.” PC World (link dead) takes a first look on Zune media player and concludes that Zune shows impressive polish for a first effort, but the Zune’s features don’t seem compelling enough to make it a serious threat to take a big chunk out of iPod sales. So far, the Zune looks like a solid addition to the MP3 player market. It’s a nice-looking player and appears to be a decent value.
IGN reviews Microsoft iPod-killer and concludes with overall rating of 8.1 out of 10 that “the Zune has both strengths and weaknesses. While the overall tone reads negative, we must admit we like the hardware. Quite a lot actually. We like holding the Zune, we like the user interface, we like watching videos on it. We like the potential of the WiFi. We like the fact that it’s not an iPod. There’s also plenty that we don’t like, but most of our greatest complaints don’t directly affect our experience of walking down the street using the Zune (especially since the majority of our music isn’t DRM’ed and we encoded all our favorite videos to the Zune easily.) In the time that the Zune has been in the IGN offices a fair number of editors have made the decision to make the switch. Until Apple blows the Zune out of the water with the long rumored touch-screen iPod, the Zune is one of our favorite mp3 players on the market.”
PC Magazine concludes with good rating of 3.5 out of 5 that tight software integration, a subscription plan, and slick design make the Zune an interesting, if not compelling, iPod alternative. Zune has nice design, easy-to use, three-inch screen, wireless music & photo sharing with other Zunes plus good integration with software. However, it has small hard drive, non-replaceable battery, weak Battery Life, no PlaysForSure support and no Podcasts or Video offering in Zune marketplace.
Washington Post concludes that Zune’s relentlessly proprietary nature suggests Microsoft drew the wrong lessons from Apple: It matched the restrictiveness of the iTunes Store, not its utility. The Zune player itself is the most appealing part of the package. About the size of a deck of cards, it comes in dark gray, brown or white and provides almost 30 gigabytes of hard-drive storage. It has an intuitiveness absent from most other iPod rivals. Incompatibility with other Windows Media-based online music stores should provoke a lot more angst. Zune software and hardware only play “unprotected” MP3, AAC and WMA files, plus Zune Marketplace downloads. They ignore anything obtained before from stores using Microsoft’s formats. Rhapsody, Napster or MSN Music songs, audiobook loans from a library, Amazon Unbox video rentals–they’re all dead to the Zune. This is a breathtaking display of corporate faithlessness, cluelessness or both.
XBL Radio (link dead) concludes that “overall I am pretty happy that I bought one, it a pretty cool device. Now would I recommend you guys to buy one? That all depends on your situation, do you need a mp3 player? Do you already have one? And what features are you looking for? If you already have and iPod I say keep your iPod for right now. Right now you can not really do anything extra with the Zune compared to the iPod. If you do not have an mp3 player and want to get one I would really recommend the Zune, especially if your a 360 gamer because of the integration that will be coming our way.” Chicago Sun-Times (link dead) predicts that the Zune will be dead and gone within six months due to the facts that Zune is a complete, humiliating failure. Toshiba’s Gigabeat player, for example, is far more versatile, it has none of the Zune’s limitations, and Amazon sells the 30-gig model for 40 bucks less. Throw in the Zune’s tail-wagging relationship with music publishers, and it almost becomes important that you encourage people not to buy one. Companies such as Toshiba and Sandisk (with its wonderful Nano-like Sansa e200 series) compete effectively with the iPod by asking themselves, “What are the things that users want and Apple refuses to provide?” Microsoft’s colossal blunder was to knock the user out of that question and put the music industry in its place.